COMPARISON OF BUSINESS STRUCTURES IN SAUDI ARABIA
The information on these structures were gathered through research in the side business entities in Saudi Arabia and insights from SJSCs Vs LLCs Under New Saudi Companies Law, which focuses on the introduction of SJSCs under the current legal reforms.
Detailed Comparison of LLCs and JSCs
When we talk about holding or parent entities, the choice is between LLCs, JSCs, and SJSCs, with SJSCs being a recent addition to the list, based on A Comparison between Limited Liability Company and Closed Joint-Stock Company in KSA.
Below is a comparison between Limited Liability Company and Closed Joint-Stock Company in KSA:
- Number of Shareholders: LLCs are limited to 1-50 partners, while JSCs have no upper limit, requiring at least 2 shareholders (single shareholder possible for specific cases with capital >SAR 5M).
- Capital Requirements: As per MISA guidelines set by Saudi there is no minimum requirement of capital for an LLC company; it is based and determined on their type of activity. For a foreign-owned JSC entity, the investment is SAR 200M commitment over 5 years based on Types of Business Licenses in Saudi Arabia.
- Liability: LLCs and CJSCs both offer limited liability to safeguard the shareholders’ personal assets to their investments.
- Management: LLCs are managed by a single manager or board making it flexible and easier, and JSCs need a formal board of directors (3-11 members).
- Share Transferability: LLC shares are not publicly traded, while JSC shares can be traded, especially for public JSCs that are listed on Tadawul.
- Regulatory Compliance: LLCS have a simpler set of requirements to be followed, which is mentioned in Types of Companies in Saudi Arabia – 2024, however, JSCs are required to follow a stricter set of requirements.
- Public Listing: If an LLC company wants to be listed publicly, it needs to be converted to JSC and JSCs can be listed without any further requirements, making capital market accessible to them.
ROLE OF SIMPLIFIED JOINT-STOCK COMPANIES (SJSCS)
SJSCs, introduced under recent legal reforms, offer a middle ground. Research from How to establish a simplified joint stock company in Saudi Arabia states that they are meant for Small to medium enterprises, with no requirement for minimum capital, flexible share issuance, and possibility of listing. While not explicitly stated as holding companies, their features—such as ease of share transfer and suitability for venture capital—suggest they could be used for medium-sized parent entities, as per SJSCs Vs LLCs Under the New Saudi Companies Law.
Factors Influencing Choice
The choice of structure depends on many factors, please look at your organisational group and consider the following:
- Size and Scale: Parent entities that are small in size would want to go with LLCs for simplicity, and the larger parent entities would want to stick with JSCs reason being they have multiple subsidiaries.
- Capital Needs: LLCs prefer going for private funding, and JSCs require public funding because of their potential for being listed.
- Foreign Ownership: LLCs allow 100% foreign ownership without high capital, as per Establishing a Saudi company by foreigners, while JSCs have stricter rules.
- Regulatory Compliance: LLCs offer fewer burdens, making them easier to manage, while JSCs require more formal governance.
- Long-term Plans: If public listing is anticipated, starting as a JSC or SJSC is strategic; otherwise, LLCs provide initial flexibility.
Practical Considerations and Examples
For instance, a foreign investor establishing a small holding company to manage regional subsidiaries might choose an LLC for its flexibility and 100% ownership, avoiding the high capital requirements of JSCs. Conversely, a large conglomerate aiming to raise capital through Tadawul might opt for a JSC, leveraging its ability to list and attract public investment. SJSCs could appeal to medium-sized entities, such as family businesses expanding into new sectors, seeking growth without the complexity of traditional JSCs.
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Selecting the right legal structure for your parent entity in Saudi Arabia requires balancing flexibility, compliance, and growth potential. LLCs are ideal for smaller, private holding companies, JSCs for larger, capital-intensive entities, and SJSCs for medium-sized businesses with growth ambitions. Given the complexity of Saudi regulations, please get in contact with the team at Creation Business Consultants to ensure compliance and optimize your structure.
By understanding these nuances, you can lay a solid foundation for your parent entity, setting it up for success in Saudi Arabia’s dynamic business environment, and leave potential openings and opportunities for potential future capital raising efforts.
Contact Creation Business Consultants at [email protected], Saudi Arabia +966 56 865 2329, or UAE +971 4 878 6240 to set up your KSA parent company with confidence.